Mafia V Extravaganza!: Streets of Betaville (Mafia wins!)
- Thread starter Flaming_Tiki_God
- Start date
crazycracker22
Rookie
Lunch JCD!
Rekkie7
Rookie
Trippysmurf said:
Great logic :roll: We could of killed 5 more townies by now.
We've done the right thing up until now.
But I agree on the future course. Without cops our only choice is to lynch.
NickKmet, from the count I'm pretty sure we have 3 mafia left. If one of them is JCD when we've reduced it to 2. One obviously is The Godfather and there isn't much you can help with that. The last regular mafia member wouldn't come up clean on your scans so we need a list of everyone you've scanned.
Then we focus on lynching the non-scanned first because we know there is at least 1 mafia member there.
Lynch JCD
NickKmet
Regular
sorry Rekkie, you are correct, there will be 2 more left if JCD is a mafia member.
Anyways, out of those that are alive, these are the people we've scanned that come up innocent.
Longo
Rekkie7
Kapow
everyone else we've scanned is dead. But remember, any of those 3 could be the godfather.
Anyways, out of those that are alive, these are the people we've scanned that come up innocent.
Longo
Rekkie7
Kapow
everyone else we've scanned is dead. But remember, any of those 3 could be the godfather.
keepithowitis
Rookie
Wait, how can we be sure Nick is even a cop? The Mafia have done things like that before. They've been amazingly smart this game, I wouldn't expect them to try something like that.
NickKmet
Regular
unfortunately for you, no, i'm not pretending to be a cop.
Now, i'm not saying for sure that JCD is mafia. I scanned him, and he came up positive. He could have been framed though. Trust me, or don't trust me, i'm probably gonna be dead by the next night anyway if the mafia has any brains.
Now, i'm not saying for sure that JCD is mafia. I scanned him, and he came up positive. He could have been framed though. Trust me, or don't trust me, i'm probably gonna be dead by the next night anyway if the mafia has any brains.
Rekkie7
Rookie
keepithowitis said:
If he wasn't he'ld be dead in days.
It's never been in the mafia's best interests to claim they are cops, it singles them out and the real cop would know if they were lieing.
So trusting him for now is win - win.
Good work cops, you've found out a good number of mafia. Shame the innocients you found mostly died but at least we've got something to go on.
Chris_Crime
Rookie
Rekkie7 said:
keepithowitis
Rookie
Except for the fact that there is only one cop.
I'm not saying that I disagree with anybody here, I'm just slightly suspicious about what's been happening recently in the game.
I'm not saying that I disagree with anybody here, I'm just slightly suspicious about what's been happening recently in the game.
Trippysmurf
Rookie
keepithowitis said:
Are you trying to suggest that you are actually the lone cop and Nick is full of crap?
Listen, Nick is dead no matter what happens - if JCD is a townie, then either the Vigilante or we will lynch him the next morning. If JCD is in the mafia, then the mafia will kill him off in the night. Nick has effectively written himself out for the game.
What we should be doing is focusing on who else is in the Mafia after tonight. There are possibly 2 people left, so we should check out voting records, who has been quiet. Who has been the quickest to call out Ghost and Nick in the past, etc.
Aside from who Nick called out as "townies" - remember one of them could be the Godfather - there are still a good number of people who I trust and don't trust. Again, we should look over past voting records, and who has been quiet as of late.
keepithowitis
Rookie
I agree with you, Trippy.. but you shouldn't suspect people just for staying quiet. Everyone has something to add to the game.
Trippysmurf
Rookie
I'm not saying those that have only contributed to this game by saying "Lynch X" - like Chris_Crime or HK-47 - are in the Mafia.
What I am saying is that anyone who didn't respond when we lynched a member of the mafia should be watched over.
What I am saying is that anyone who didn't respond when we lynched a member of the mafia should be watched over.
keepithowitis
Rookie
What, like not saying anything at all? There's reasons for that. They could be gone, or not read the lynches, or not care, or be too lazy to either say 'Lynch ____' or 'No Lynch'. This game is tough in that there's not a good way to determine who is who. The Mafia only has their teammates to communicate to. The townies, doctors and cops can all say whatever they want over the forum, in reason of not giving away their role. There are really no advantages for either side.
