I'll vote between the two based solely only these two images I found on the Google.
Pudgy Cosplay Magneto who is Pudgy
Overcompensating Halloween Punisher who Overcompensates
hm.
hm.
This is tough hm.
Too tough to decide. I'll have to vote on their facial hair. That makes sense.
_______________________
Well you have to admire the intestinal fortitude of both guys. Both are working their pose. Trés fierce.
Magneto is rocking the teenstache with a side of chin moss, and Punisher rolls with pure makeup for his stubbles.
It's close. It is very close. But I have to go with ...... Punisher! The stubble on this guy would leave any manimal jealous. The fact that he's faking the stubs only proves that his gonads are bigger than (y)ours.
Teenstache on a 30-something year old Magneto is slightly unnerving. He should have faked it, too.
Wait. Why does Magneto have facial hair in the first place? Nevermind, this battle has been decided.