MGS wins 12-2.
Final Fantasy 7 (1)
VS.
Silent Hill (2)
Both games ended up living up to the seeding, getting to the division finals. Silent Hill is the new kid on the block, showing off it's newfound popularity these last two years, but Final Fantasy VII hit it's popularity groove two years ago as well and has yet to fall off it's perch. I thought FF7 might have dropped off enough over the last year to fall to Link to the Past, but that match wasn't even close, so it hasn't lost it yet. This should be epic.
I vote FF7.
May the best game win.