I think it would be about Duke being captured, and GR Staff members unite with other people to save him amd eventually the whole video game community in a traditional RPG way. The final boss would be CNet who decided to destroy video game reviewing by capturing all the reviewers on the internet and replacing them with robot look-alikes programmed to give every game perfect scores. This remains unknown till the near the end. But all that is known is that a terrorist group is attacking various cities (websites). Since GR is a smaller than Gamespot or IGN, it is attacked later than many of the others. They get a message simply stating "Hide". Before any action can be done a group of soldiers bust in and kidnap Duke as well as many other staff members. Nick, Joe, and one other person escape through a portal that Joe created and have to fight to save the world.
Soon you team up with three other characters who represent Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo. Joe will be a Mage, both black and white, and one of his specials will be Reprogram, where he decreases all of an opponents stats. Nick will be a thief/ninja and will be able to poison enemies. The Microsoft guy will be a gunner, with the Red Ring special ability which will have a 1/3 chance of an instant kill. The Sony guy will be a knight with a Blu-ray attack that would be like a Shoop-Da-Whoop for humor. And the Nintendo character would be a fighter with nunchuks.
And Jack Thompson would be an optional boss, but as you fight him your money slowly disappears, and when you run out the battle is over.