To be totally honest, though both have their share of flaws, I preferred the previous attempt to reboot Superman with Brandon Routh (sp?) than that most recent attempt. The main criticism of that other one was that it boring, slow, blah blah, but they swung the pendulum too far in the other direction with the re-reboot and the thing was just a headache inducing orgy of CGI destruction and noise by the end of the film.
This new one looks like they are trying to shoehorn all these characters into one film and are going to have to find a way to make sure non comic book people know what the hell is going on since the characters aren't getting their own introduction films to tie them into the main film like Marvel did with their superheros.
They might be able to make it work, or they might wind up with another X-Men: Last Stand.